Mr. Saturn sprite Hoodie - Stitched or Screened?

Are you willing to pay a premium to be put in stitches?

sprite Reid Young

Fangamer Mastermind

[email protected]

Zippered Hoodies: Embroidered or Screenprinted?

(176 votes by 176 people)

We’re considering doing a hoodie design, and we can either screenprint it or get it embroidered. There are a few pros/cons when it comes to embroidery:

  • It’s more expensive -- to the tune of an extra $10-$15, bringing the total price closer to the $50 mark (we’re still not sure how much they’ll cost, but this is just a very rough estimate).
  • It lasts longer. Screenprinting cracks and wears with repeated washes, but embroidery tends to hang in there much longer.
  • An embroidered design will, by necessity, have to be smaller (to keep the cost down) whereas screenprinted hoodies can have much larger designs.

sprite Heidi Mandelin

Office Megazord

[email protected]

I had this shirt from the Pac-man Cafe that had a small embroidered Pac-man on the upper-left side of the shirt. It looked perfect and beautiful when it was brand new, but after just one wash, the sides of the Pac-man curled up and it looked really stupid. After a few more washes, it curled up so bad that you couldn’t even seen it unless I ironed it flat. That was annoying and I eventually threw the shirt away. It’s the only experience I’ve had with an embroidered shirt, so I’m wondering if the same thing might happen to this hoodie, or perhaps the Pac-man shirt was just cheap and crappy.

I am just singing about Zelda and Majora’s Mask in the Milk Bar.

Wilhelmina Carmel

Wilhelm Scream

  • dragon
  • artspot
  • fanvatar3
  • Radio PSI - 1 year

I’m pretty much indifferent towards both. I’m fine with shelling out extra cash in the future if embroidery is chosen :D

DoseiSan

Let's get freaking DANGEROUS.

  • plo
  • fanvatar3
  • fangamerHCP
  • EarthBound Central
  • Game Swag

I’m with Poe on this one, even though I haven’t had very many BAD embroidery experiences, I’ve had them get stuck in stuff and come undone and yes, slight curling and I always end up wishing it wasn’t embroidered. Screeenprinted all the way!

In another time, In another world…
Another knight enters the Tower of Druaga

sprite Kevin Williams

Fangamer Forum Administrator

[email protected]

On the contrary, I’ve always found embroidered stuff looks much better down the road, whereas screenprinting tends to start showing signs of rubbing away within six months. Back in the day (in the oldschool way) I would’ve been concerned about the price, but now I have one of them “job” thingies so caution has gone to the wind.

Baseball sure is a funny game.

sprite vdtdcutd5145

    I have a feeling it was just a crummy hoodie. An Embroidered anything ends up generally looking better and lasting much longer than screenprinted stuff, unless your using a very good and high quality material that they use in say, Soccer Jerseys. In those cases the screenprinted stuff lasted a long time.

    I’ve had to deal with Soccer and Football Jerseys, both embroidered and screenprinted, and the embroidered ones generally ended up lasting longer than screenprinted. Screenprinted ones end up getting cracked, faded or in one odd case…simply falling off. Since I’m pretty much guaranteed to have one of those "job " thingies by the time it comes on sale, I’m willing to pay around $50 for the hoodie, especially since hoodies in general aren’t that cheap anyway.

    thickfreakness

    I solve practical problems!

    • Fanart of the Week
    • fanvatar3
    • fangamerHCW
    • artspot

    screenprint representin’ in da house yo

    hello yes this is dog

    sprite Tsukimoon

      I say either.

      Personally, I like the way screenprinting looks after many uses/washes. It just feels kinda awesome.

      Kalle

      • donor1
      • Holiday Funfest 08 Winner
      • Who Arted 17 Wins

      I don’t care, as long as the sweatshirt in question can keep me cozy!

      WOAT

      sprite vdtdcutd5145

        How much longer until it’s complete and it goes on sale?

        sprite Reid Young

        Fangamer Mastermind

        [email protected]

        This is still at least a few months out.

        sprite kebby129

          Good we will get it when it starts getting cold out and we NEED sweaters.

          Firegirl

          fiery ball of fire

          • bannercontest
          • DINO RAMPAGE!
          • donor4

          I’m down for either one. I still have my frat hoodie from years ago, and it’s still in fantastic shape, and I love it. I’d like something more solid (I’m partial to zip up hoodies with pockets) that’s going to last a while yet. If I end up shelling out $55 for a hoodie, that’s awesome, because like I said before, the frat one is STILL floating around and it hasn’t had any damage done to it.

          Nesskid

          Officer Sheriff Bradley from the... Leehigh... County

          • artistorm
          • plo
          • DINO RAMPAGE!
          • HockeyMonkey Appeasement Decay

          Why so much hate for screen printing it’s a way better way of doing things. But then again I’m a little biased having taken 3 years of graphic arts/screen printing classes, and I used to work in a print shop.

          I used to be the guy, time makes fools of us all.
          Casey? /wiggles fingers

          sprite SkimHeaven

          I say Screen Printed.

          Embroidery just doesn’t seem right to me for a hoody.

          He who enjoys life wins at life.

          Nothings changed, its just been rearranged.

          Nesskid

          Officer Sheriff Bradley from the... Leehigh... County

          • artistorm
          • plo
          • DINO RAMPAGE!
          • HockeyMonkey Appeasement Decay

          Embroidery to me just reeks of family reunion shirts.

          I used to be the guy, time makes fools of us all.
          Casey? /wiggles fingers

          sprite RaiderX

            I’d love to see a THIN hoodie design. I like hoodies, and would love to buy a SM.net one, but I live in Florida, and heavy hoodies are only bearable maybe a month out of the year.

            sig.

            sprite vdtdcutd5145

              Sad about the more time needed but glad to hear it’ll be here when the cold season comes. In DC, it started in late November but stretched all the way out til March so I’ll definitely need a new hoodie.

              DC weather and very weird and finicky. But i’ll be heading up to Chicago or NY for college in a year or 2 so cold weather gear is a must for either.

              sprite Spitball Sparky

              • fangamerHCP
              • dragon
              • EarthBound Central

              Stitched. It looks classy. Screened is cheap.

              Nesskid

              Officer Sheriff Bradley from the... Leehigh... County

              • artistorm
              • plo
              • DINO RAMPAGE!
              • HockeyMonkey Appeasement Decay

              I used to be the guy, time makes fools of us all.
              Casey? /wiggles fingers

              Firegirl

              fiery ball of fire

              • bannercontest
              • DINO RAMPAGE!
              • donor4
              Embroidery to me just reeks of family reunion shirts.

              Oh man! All the family reunion shirts I’ve seen are either really crappy iron-ons, baaaaad airbrush, or screen-printed. I can honestly say I’ve never seen an embroidered family reunion article of clothing.

              sprite kebby129

                wait does anyone know what the design is going to be? It would be cool to have a giygas one like the one on the icon for merch.

                sprite Heidi Mandelin

                Office Megazord

                [email protected]

                ^ You mean at the top of the forum? No can do, since it’s a direct copy of the original design. Meeellla is working on a stylized design that I personally guarantee will knock your socks off (and I’ve only seen the beta designs so far!).

                I am just singing about Zelda and Majora’s Mask in the Milk Bar.

                sprite kebby129

                  oh ok i was just wondering what it would be

                  sprite vdtdcutd5145

                    I asked this about another piece of clothing…But how many hoodies do you guys estimate you will have ready by the time they go on sale?

                    sprite Reid Young

                    Fangamer Mastermind

                    [email protected]

                    We’ll print more than enough to cover demand, that way we’ll have enough to sell next year during hoodie season. No worries there

                    sprite NoGoodFly

                    I’d be willing to pay a premium for anything Earthbound related. However, I’m not a huge hoodie fan. Mainly because I’d want it in small/extra small so it’d fit well in the chest/body, but then more than likely the sleeves would be super short (it’s aways an issue I have with sweaters/hoodies/sweatshirts). I still like the idea of embroidering, though.

                    sprite kebby129

                      since either is winning what would you choose? Embroyded or stitched, or selling both.

                      sprite vdtdcutd5145

                        Awesome to hear

                        YOU CALLIN ME CRAZY!? oh wai..

                        • donor4
                        • plo
                        • blanko
                        • fangamerHCP
                        • EarthBound Central
                        • Reid is a Jinjo

                        Both have there cons and there pro’s so I put either

                        why is life so unfair. Thy hatred is unjust, you jest? “why” “GNAUT” can i vote for all YE

                        sprite Aka_Kiba

                          I’m Catholic, everything is against my religion. Everything connects to something.

                          I love the smell of Pk Rockin in the morning.
                          My Weekend Job
                          Real Men Don’t Use Forks

                          sprite Zip Code Ness

                          • fangamerHCP

                          I bought this screen printed hoodie in the Bazaar once in Jerusalem. It was the coca-cola symbol in Hebrew on a black hoodie. After awhile it started to chip away, and the black color started to fade away. It used to be my favorite hoodie that I would wear even in the Fall and Spring, but now I can’t stand it.

                          Look lady, I speak only two languages, English and Bad English. – Korben Dallas, The Fifth Element

                          sprite legotrekker

                            I’m Catholic, everything is against my religion. Everything connects to something.

                            Was that a serious comment?

                            I like screenprinted better myself.

                            sprite KirbyBlu

                              I really don’t know the difference, so Screenprinted ftw, I guess.

                              Ness used PK CALLIN’! It’s super effective!

                              sprite Gizzmo

                              I have no job. Screenprinted = win.

                              And besides, I want to proudly boast my fandom, so people from at least 9000 feet away should be able to see what the heck is on my hoodie.

                              sprite reno7

                              • donor1

                              I’m down for either one.

                              sprite npjpkac

                                As far as I am concerned, if it is comfortable, I will wear it, fo’ sho’. But, zips usually are my choice. I definitely want some of those new shirts, College is coming up…;)

                                sprite somaticdefilement

                                • donor1
                                • dragon
                                • EarthBound Central
                                • Wess Butt

                                screen printed hoodies look more legit and seem to allow for more versatility

                                Drütopia

                                No Day but Drü-day

                                • poe
                                • mafia
                                The only kinds of zippered hoodies that are against my religion are the ones that don't zip up all the way to the top so I can cover my face and look like a total gangster.
                                • ∞ used ATMA>apps>HiddenPowerEmulator>HellFire . . .
                                • the Medical Bill went up in flames!
                                • (∞) “Heh . . . cool.”

                                sprite Yokai

                                  How small are we talking for the embroidered design compared to the screenprinted one? Can we get an estimate?

                                  mackincheese

                                  Virtual Mission?

                                  • fangamerHCP
                                  • donor5

                                  Well, I was all about the embroidered hoodie until I heard about this “curling up” that might take place, so now I’m going to have to go with screenprinted. For sure.

                                  Because…shut up, that’s why.

                                  sprite Spitball Sparky

                                  • fangamerHCP
                                  • dragon
                                  • EarthBound Central

                                  I’m Catholic, so I’m sure hoodies are a sin according to one pope or the other.

                                  But it’s a good sin. >:3

                                  sprite EBP

                                  • EarthBound Central

                                  i is of no religion…besides happy-happyism… and i say screen-printed, so longs as the printed is done to the quality that the WWE hoodies are… man i has washed them and they still look just like the day i got them…same can’t be said for the shirts though

                                  - The Reckoning

                                  STEAM

                                  sprite PKVorpalStorm

                                  When PK Starstorm Ω isn't enough

                                  • donor3

                                  Either way, really. There are pros and cons to both. While I do prefer HUGE designs, embroidery had a feel that you can’t beat.

                                  “Starfall. Druids get Starfall? I GET F**CKING PK STARSTORM, BABY!”

                                  sprite Heidi Mandelin

                                  Office Megazord

                                  [email protected]

                                  Well, I was all about the embroidered hoodie until I heard about this "curling up" that might take place, so now I’m going to have to go with screenprinted. For sure.

                                  Well see, I’m pretty sure the quality of the shirt had a lot to do with it. The shirt was thin, and a hoodie will be much thicker, no doubt. Plus, the design was a small, almost perfect circle, which probably made it even easier to succumb to curling up.

                                  I got this other shirt with an embroidered logo on it last month. My mom brought it down from Spokane, WA. It’s not a circle, and it doesn’t have any white “paper” sewn into the back of the shirt like the Pacman design did, and it’s still perfectly fine. Washed it many times and it’s still in good shape.

                                  I dunno, I guess I was waiting for reid to either confirm my experience or reassure me that it was an isolated case when I made that post up there.

                                  I am just singing about Zelda and Majora’s Mask in the Milk Bar.

                                  sprite Reid Young

                                  Fangamer Mastermind

                                  [email protected]

                                  I’ll have to hear from Jon about that — I don’t have very much experience with embroidery.

                                  sprite MobleSprout

                                  • EarthBound Central

                                  I’m going to have to throw my weight behind screened – not only to keep price down, but I find that screened hoodies just generally look more fashionable. If it’s printed with a good ink, I’ve had shirts that have lasted regular wear for almost five years without losing any noticeable amount of the image.

                                  Plus, screenprints just feel much nicer to the touch and look better in the light.

                                  sprite dsinger

                                    I accidentally voted for Embroidered. Screenprinted should be fine.

                                    sprite PKSkyler

                                    • EarthBound Central
                                    • !! Undertale Birthday

                                    Honestly, I dont like hoodies much

                                    sprite GuitarGuy

                                    I would totally buy a hoodie from you guys if you made one! To be honest, I would be more happy with an embriodered one. It’s just that they seem more official and I wouldn’t mind paying extra for any Mother merchandise. It would be really neat if you guys could do some sort of combo. I’m just tossing out an idea here, but it would be make for an awsome hoodie if you could get and embroidered Starmen emblem near the top with a screen printed design elswhere on the hoodie. So you could maybe have that giygas design on the torso with an official starmen emblem near the heart. I would buy that in a heart beat